Ah, the joys of family gatherings during the holidays. We all know how stressful they can be, especially when it comes to planning the perfect feast. But what happens when one family member’s tight budget clashes with the rest of the family’s expectations? In this story, a young woman in her 20s, let’s call her ‘Budget Belle’, finds herself in a Christmas conundrum when her frugal brother takes issue with her proposed menu. ️
The Family Tradition

A Change of Venue

Budget Belle’s Role

The Menu Proposal

Frugal Brother’s Response

The Cost of Christmas

Cutting Back ️

Budget Belle’s Response ️

Brother’s Justification

Last Year’s Drama

The Bold Solution

Brother’s Reaction

The Aftermath ️

A Kind Request ❤️

Christmas Chaos: Who’s the Real Grinch?
So, what do we have here? A family Christmas turned upside down by a frugal brother’s menu choices, leaving Budget Belle feeling like she ruined the holidays. With her brother unwilling to compromise, she suggests not attending the celebration altogether, sparking even more drama. Now, everyone’s mad, and Christmas plans are up in the air. ️ But amidst the chaos, Budget Belle still finds it in her heart to encourage others to donate to those in need during the holiday season. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this festive fiasco…
Brother’s frugality ruins sister’s Christmas meal, commenters debate NTA/ESH.

Family charged for holiday meal? NTA brother’s attitude is questionable


Frugal brother charges student sibling for Christmas dinner, gets called out.

Cooking for a family Christmas can be a hassle

Hosts should accommodate dietary restrictions. Don’t exclude guests.

Toxic family dynamics ruin Christmas dinner plans
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/da3cbf55-921f-42f3-8056-0eac83876d9d.png)

Frugal brother causes drama over one dish at Christmas

NTA shuts down whiny brother with a dose of reality


![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/93f10585-953a-42df-b68e-f66b65e3e64c.png)
Supportive comment receives no replies.

Brother’s stinginess ruins Christmas for family

Frugal brother causes family drama over Christmas menu

Brother’s frugality causes Christmas food feud

NTA for stepping away from a miserly brother’s last-minute change.

Frugal brother doesn’t want to host Christmas, NTA suggests taking away role

Brother causes drama over Christmas dinner menu

A vegan option for $5-6? Not bad at all

Frugal brother refuses to pay $5-6 for vegan options

OP is NTA for standing up for herself against brother’s weird flex.

Brother’s frugality causes drama at family Christmas dinner. NTA handles gracefully.

Frugal brother defends vegan spread against costly non-vegan alternative

Frugal brother’s Christmas menu causes family feud
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/9a479041-79ac-42e0-9659-561f99979cb0.png)
Elegant response to exclusion at family Christmas dinner

Sibling tension rises over grocery budget at Christmas dinner

NTA suggests potluck, sparks no discussion in replies.

Frugal brother gets served a taste of his own medicine

Generous holiday spirit clashes with frugal family member. NTA wins.

Cooking for everyone else for free is not charity. NTA!

NTA stands their ground against frugal brother’s Christmas menu choices

Cooking for free just for his presence? NTA

Brother’s frugality ruins Christmas dinner, commenter says NTA

Sarcasm detected! Brother is NTA according to commenter.

Contributing to family Christmas costs is fair, but penny-pinching isn’t.

Being alive costs money. Making and eating food costs money.

Encouraging response to brother’s emotional behavior during Christmas dinner.

Brother refuses to accommodate dietary restrictions for Christmas dinner



Considerate commenter prioritizes family’s dietary needs during holidays

Potlucks are the way to go for affordable holiday meals!

Generous Christmas contributions unappreciated by entitled family members

Commenter suggests excluding frugal brother from Christmas festivities.

NTA stands up to frugal brother’s unrealistic demands

Nostalgic advice for family disputes during Christmas dinner

Family first: A heartwarming take on Christmas and inclusivity

Frugal brother ruins Christmas dinner, suggests hosting at parents’ house instead

Standing up for oneself: NTA doesn’t let brother ruin Christmas

OP’s sassy response to potential holiday drama

Frugal brother causes family drama, but maybe it’s time for change

Contributing to a meal is one thing ♂️ Bringing a dish or a bottle of wine is normal Itemizing and charging seems insane

Suggests potluck or desserts only for family Christmas dinner

Southern family doesn’t split costs for holiday meals, just contribute sides.

Family Christmas potluck saves the day, frugal brother needs perspective

Simplify Christmas dinner by making it a potluck.

Supportive comment, calling out selfish behavior with holiday wishes

Brother’s frugality causes family feud

Simplify Christmas dinner with a potluck and enjoy stress-free holidays

Brother demands elaborate meal but throws fit over one dish. NTA.

Family drama over Christmas costs and frugal brother’s complaints

Agreeing with OP, commenters dislike brother’s behavior

Setting boundaries: Saying no to hosting without guilt

Guests shouldn’t be charged for anything. NTA for skipping.
