Fiancé Gifts My Sick Brother’s Christmas Present To His Nephew: AITA?

A woman bought an Xbox for her sick brother as a Christmas gift. However, her fiancé took it and gave it to his nephew, who lives states away. The woman confronted her fiancé, who argued that he was trying to help his sister out. The woman called it theft and demanded her fiancé pay for the Xbox. The situation caused a rift between the couple. The woman is now seeking advice on whether he was in the wrong for calling it theft. Read on to find out more.

Heartbreaking story of a sick brother and his limitations.

Brother can’t afford console. A**hole fiancé gifts it away.

Heartless fiancé steals sick brother’s Christmas gift: AITA?

Fiancé gifts Xbox meant for sick brother to nephew: AITA?

Fiancé gives sick brother’s gift to nephew: Is it acceptable?

Fiancé gifts sick brother’s Xbox to nephew: Justified or theft?

Fiancé gifted sick brother’s present to nephew: conflict and solution

Fiancé gifted sick brother’s present to nephew. AITA for feeling hurt?

Fiancé gifts brother’s present to nephew: AITA?

When a woman bought her sick brother an Xbox as a Christmas present, she was devastated to find out that her fiancé had gifted it to his nephew instead. The woman’s brother’s heart condition has prevented him from doing many things he enjoys, and she wanted to give him a console to cheer him up. However, her fiancé took the Xbox and sent it to his single-mother sister’s son, who said he would not receive any other gifts. The woman was upset and called her fiancé a thief, leading to a fight in which her fiancé left for a hotel for three days. The woman now wonders if she is in the wrong for being upset about the situation. While her fiancé may have had good intentions, he crossed a line by taking something not his to give. What do you think? Was the fiancé in the wrong, or was he trying to help his sister and nephew out? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

NTA: Commenters question fiancé’s motives and suggest legal action.

Demand money back, he stole and called it a “good deed”

Fiance gifts sick brother’s Christmas present to nephew: Commenters say he’s TA.

Fiancé steals from sick brother, gaslights OP: commenters call out ableism

Sister’s boyfriend cheats and nephew may have stolen gift: Drama!

Fiancé’s selfishness and disregard for family is a red flag

Fiancé gifts sick brother’s present to nephew: Red flag?

Commenter defends OP and calls out thief’s ableism and narcissism ‍♀️

Fiancé steals sick brother’s Christmas present for nephew: Outrage ensues

Fiancé stole and gifted sick brother’s present to nephew: Breakup territory

Commenter suggests package intercept to resolve issue: ❗

Dump his a**!

Replacing a gift for $300+? NTA according to commenters

Partner’s entitlement and gaslighting raises red flags. Stand firm.

Fiancé steals sick brother’s gift for nephew. NTA.

Suggesting a sneaky way to recover the funds ️‍♀️

Fiancé’s theft and lack of remorse: NTA

Standing up for what’s right

Furious OP calls out fiancé for stealing sick brother’s gift: NTA

Support for NTA’s decision to leave insensitive fiancé. ❤️

BF steals sick brother’s gift for nephew: Commenters agree he’s TA

Stealing from a sick kid? Not cool. Dump-worthy behavior

Redditors doubt authenticity of story about stolen Christmas present.

Homeless brother, hotel-staying fiancé, and a gift controversy

Commenter defends OP, calls out thief in blunt manner

Factual statement: Fiancé gifts nephew, not sick brother. NTA.

Take action! NTA should involve the police

Fiancé steals sick brother’s gift. Red flag for marriage?

Commenter suggests calling the police on thief fiancé.

Defending the sick brother’s stolen gift: NTA vs. entitled thief

Stand your ground! NTA. Give him an ultimatum. ⏰

Commenter uses ‘narcissist’s prayer’ to declare NTA.

Fiancé stole brother’s gift, now payback time: NTA

When Judge Judy becomes the moral compass we need

Suggesting to call police and break up with thief

Boyfriend steals sick brother’s gift for entitled nephew: NTA

Fiancé gifts sick brother’s present to nephew: NTA, it’s theft.

Fiancé steals sick brother’s gift for nephew: justified outrage.

Boyfriend’s “good deed” steals sick brother’s gift: NTA.

Fiancé gifts sick brother’s present to nephew: gaslights and refuses refund

Dump him! NTA for considering pressing charges. ️‍♀️

Fiancé gifts brother’s present to nephew: OP feels hurt, betrayed.

Partner stole sick brother’s gift: NTA, end relationship

Boyfriend steals Christmas present, gets offended when called out: NTA

Commenter advises filing theft report and finding better partner

Commenter calls out AH fiancé and suggests breaking up

Fiancé gifts brother’s present to nephew: NTA suggests ultimatum

Fiancé steals Xbox meant for sick brother’s nephew: NTA’s angry response.

Fiancé steals sick brother’s gift: OP is NTA

Fiancé steals sick brother’s gift: Commenters agree, NTA

Commenter accuses fiancé of theft: