We’ve all heard the debate about participation trophies and whether they help or hinder a child’s development. But what happens when a family is divided over this contentious issue? One dad found himself in the hot seat after refusing to let his wife give their son a participation trophy for a spelling bee. The 12-year-old placed 5th out of 28, but only the top 3 received trophies. The boy was understandably upset, and his mom wanted to have a trophy made for him. However, dad put his foot down, sparking a heated debate. Let’s dive into the story.
The Spelling Bee Situation
Proud Parents, Disappointed Son
The Results Are In
Mom’s Solution: A Custom Trophy
Dad’s Disapproval
The Participation Trophy Debate
Mom’s Fury
Dad’s Intentions
Wife’s Concerns
Celebrating Their Son’s Achievement
Overwhelming Response
The Final Decision
The Great Trophy Debate: Who’s Right? ♂️
In the end, this family’s disagreement over a participation trophy has sparked a larger conversation about the pros and cons of such awards. The dad stands firm in his belief that his son should earn a trophy through hard work and dedication, while the mom worries about her son’s self-esteem and social standing. They ultimately decide to celebrate their son’s achievement with a special dinner and continued encouragement. But the debate rages on: are participation trophies helpful or harmful? And who’s right in this family feud? Let’s see what the internet has to say…
RELATED STORIES
Teaching kids to lose gracefully > participation trophies
Teaching kids to cope with losing is crucial
Participation trophies have age-dependent benefits and downfalls.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/8a67e481-b02a-4789-a211-4b8874fa1e5d.png)
Parenting advice sparks debate in comment section
Encouraging dad and wife both want the best for son
Participation trophy debate: NAH, but some think they’re harmful.
Participation trophies for 12 y/o kids: Are they appropriate?
Educator suggests asking son’s motivations and getting a different token.
Participation trophies are bull, stunting social growth or not?
Teaching kids to lose graciously and work towards goals
Participation trophies: overblown issue or valuable lesson?
NTA dad refuses mom’s participation trophy for son, commenters agree
Encouraging kids to embrace failure and focus on self-improvement
NTA but watch your language, it can come off as a**holish.
Commenter suggests alternative to participation trophies with humor
Debate over the definition of a “participation trophy”
Debate over participation trophies and parenting styles.
Celebrating effort over participation trophies.
Losing inspires us to try harder.
Consolation dinner for son after no participation trophy. NTA.
YTA for not letting son have participation trophy, but valid concerns.
A reasonable suggestion for compromise and recognition of achievement
Showing up and working hard matters more than a trophy
NTA dad refuses participation trophy, teaches son effort > entitlement
Participation trophies: Harmless or harmful? NTA’s opinion explained
Nostalgic inquiry sparks mysterious disappearance of commenter.
NTA commenter defends mom’s one-off trophy for disappointed son
Celebrating with a meal beats a fake trophy any day!
Celebrating achievement without participation trophy: a productive parenting approach
Teaching life skills > participation trophies
Teaching kids to work hard and earn trophies
Proud dad rejects participation trophy, sparks debate on entitlement issues
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/6f6039a6-03f4-4ec5-b12a-83c6af9cbe5b.png)
Teaching resilience or tough love? NTA parent sparks debate.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/ed3c1010-7d40-4af4-9bd4-874c0adabaf0.png)
Skipping the participation trophy: good or bad parenting move?
NAH, both parents want son to succeed, focus on effort
12-year-old calls out participation trophy BS, NTA dad agrees
NTA educator suggests celebrating small successes but not giving participation trophies.
ESH except for your kid. Productive communication needed.
NTA dad refuses participation trophy for 12-year-old son.
Reward effort, not just results!
Learning to cope with disappointment is important. NTA
Teaching kids the value of hard work and effort! NTA
Participation trophies can kill ambition and lead to embarrassment
Teaching kids to handle failure is important for their growth
Letting kids experience disappointment is important.
No participation trophies in life? NTA takes a stand.
Teaching kids to cope with disappointment > participation trophies
Participation trophies for kids: souvenir or waste of money?
Rewarding effort in a meaningful way > participation trophies. NTA
From YTA to NTA: A Trophy Dilemma Resolved
Participation trophies: Harmful or helpful? One commenter’s experience says harmful.
Spelling Bee participant defends no participation trophies – NTA
Mother upset about trophy, not child. Parenting or entitlement?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/434cd623-0e54-4875-ac3e-975430d42749.png)
Encouraging dad teaches son value of hard work and goal-setting!
Childhood experience shows why participation trophies can be detrimental.
Skipping participation fees for older kids. NTA wins!
Participant trophies are overrated, NTA for refusing one.
Participation trophies: growth stunt or harmless reward?
Millennial weighs in on participation trophies, confusion ensues ♀️
Participation trophies can be demotivating and unfair to winners
