Man REFUSES To Give Fiancée Family Heirloom Ring After She LOSES $4K Engagement Ring 💍😱

Diply Social Team
Diply | Diply

🔥 Buckle up, folks! We've got a juicy tale of love, loss, and family heirlooms that'll have you on the edge of your seat! 😱 Our protagonist, a 27-year-old man, finds himself in a sticky situation with his 29-year-old fiancée. 💍 The issue at hand? A precious family ring with a scandalous past and a whole lot of sentimental value. 💎 Will he give it to his beloved, despite her tendency to misplace things? 🤔 Or will he save it for a future daughter? 👶 Get ready for a wild ride filled with drama, tears, and a shocking elevator incident that'll leave you gasping! 😲

💍 A Tale of Two Rings: The Heirloom Dilemma 😱

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

🔍 Backstory: The Scandalous Origins of a Cherished Ring 🙊

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

💔 A Deathbed Confession and a Priceless Gift 😢

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

👵 Aunt's Wishes: Passing the Torch to the Next Generation 🔥

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

💑 Fast Forward: A Proposal and a $4k Ring 💍

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

🤦‍♀️ The Elevator Shaft Incident: A Ring Lost Forever 😱

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

🕳️ Down the Elevator Shaft: A Shocking Revelation 😲

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

💕 Understanding Fiancé: A Cheaper Replacement Ring 💍

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

🤔 Cousin's Question: Why Not the Family Ring? 🤷‍♀️

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

😢 Fiancée's Disappointment: A Hurtful Revelation 💔

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

😬 Admitting Concerns: The Fear of Losing the Ring 😰

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

🗣️ Sister's Accusation: Is He a Jackass? 🤬

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

🔍 The Search for the Lost Ring: A Futile Effort 😞

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

📏 Ring Sizing: Not the Issue 💍

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

💰 Insured and Replaced: A Silver Lining 🌤️

soft_lab5797 | soft_lab5797

😱 Family Heirloom Heartbreak: Should He Have Given Her the Ring? 💍

Well, well, well! 👀 It seems our protagonist is caught between a rock and a hard place. 🪨 On one hand, he has a cherished family ring with a scandalous history that his aunt entrusted him to give to someone special. 💍 On the other, he has a fiancée with a habit of losing things, as evidenced by the shocking elevator shaft incident. 😱 His decision not to give her the ring has led to tears, accusations of being a jackass, and a whole lot of drama. 🎭 The internet is divided on this one, folks! 🗳️ Some say he should have trusted his fiancée with the ring, while others believe he made the right call. 🤔 What do you think? Let's dive into the juiciest responses and see what the masses have to say! 🍿

NTA: The risk was worth it. Family heirloom spared. 🙌

kayleykk2020 | kayleykk2020

Protecting family heirloom from butter fingers 👀💍

[deleted] | [deleted]

Fiancée loses $4K ring, wants heirloom ring instead. NTA.

Clean-Passenger384 | Clean-Passenger384

Fiancée loses expensive ring down elevator shaft, man called YTA until reading comment.

loloannd | loloannd

Family heirloom not an engagement ring. GF needs to understand.

Balipaper | Balipaper

Losing the first ring is unfortunate, get a moissanite replacement 💍

zaftig_stig | zaftig_stig

Fiancée loses $4K ring, demands heirloom? NTA calls out entitlement 😱

HowardProject | HowardProject

Using a family heirloom for a proposal ring is different. NTA 👍

jdownes316 | jdownes316

Yikes! This comment is not optimistic about their future together 🤨

nhcub84 | nhcub84

Protecting family heirloom from potential loss, NTA. 💍

SlipperySlope80 | SlipperySlope80

Engaging ring lost, fiancée's stupidity astounds, family ring priceless -NTA

Altruistic_Shower178 | Altruistic_Shower178

Engaging reply questioning how an engagement ring was lost 🤔

starkat0w0 | starkat0w0

Fiancée loses ring, man refuses to give heirloom. NTA.

Prohibitionincurls | Prohibitionincurls

Engaging with a hint of humor: Dropping an engagement ring down an elevator shaft 😂

Chessii_Cat | Chessii_Cat

A humorous response to a seemingly absurd comment.

borg_nihilist | borg_nihilist

User questions fiancée's honesty and suggests securing family heirloom ring.

RollingKatamari | RollingKatamari

Fiancée lost engagement ring, now she wants heirloom? 🤔

jtillery1 | jtillery1

NTA empathizes with fiancee but offers helpful tips for organization.

alligator124 | alligator124

A commenter advises against giving family heirlooms to fiancées. 👍

blondieguyon_ | blondieguyon_

Protecting family heirloom > risking losing expensive jewelry 💍

Beautiful_mistakes | Beautiful_mistakes

User questions fiancée's reaction to losing expensive ring 😱

randompensamientos | randompensamientos

Poster defends fiancée and calls out sister, declares NAH.

feeshandsheeps | feeshandsheeps

Engaged man refuses to give family heirloom ring after fiancee loses ring. Commenter defends him and calls out the sister's peanut gallery behavior. NTA 👏

[deleted] | [deleted]

Honesty hurts but NTA, she needs to prove responsibility. 👍

Fine_Prune_743 | Fine_Prune_743

Buying a $4k ring for someone who loses things? NTA.

StaceysMomPlus2more | StaceysMomPlus2more

Engaged couple disagrees over lost ring, but NAH here 💍

piggymills | piggymills

Fiancé lost engagement ring and now wants family heirloom? 🤔 NTA.

Bookish4269 | Bookish4269

Trust your instincts and protect family heirlooms. 💍

AirFriedPotato | AirFriedPotato

Engaged woman loses ring, NTA for not giving heirloom ring.

canonicallysinful | canonicallysinful

Cousin stirs up trouble; fiancée realizes he has a point. NAH 👌 (except cousin)

[deleted] | [deleted]

Lost engagement ring: Did they try contacting building management? 🤔

shangib723 | shangib723

Family heirloom ring kept safe after daughter loses 4 rings 😱

Stitch-point | Stitch-point

Protecting the family ring from 'carelessness' 💍

Haunting-Aardvark709 | Haunting-Aardvark709

Potential solution - get a copy of the family ring made 💍

iorilondon | iorilondon

Fiancée loses 4K ring, demands family heirloom, NTA stands firm.

NonaOrganic | NonaOrganic

NTA, lost engagement ring, no family heirloom for her 🙄

Saltynut99 | Saltynut99

Fiancée proves she's not responsible for family ring. How'd she lose it?

Background_Alps6164 | Background_Alps6164

NTA, trust issues proved right. She needs to be careful 🙅

[deleted] | [deleted]

Defending decision to keep family heirloom ring over lost engagement ring 💍

[deleted] | [deleted]

Engaging comment sharing personal experience with heirloom ring, advises against daily use.

spicykatchup | spicykatchup

Protecting family heirlooms is important, don't give in to pressure.

annoyed68 | annoyed68

Don't give family heirloom without prenup. NTA advice. 👍

Yorella3 | Yorella3

Get organized and unfuck your habitat with this helpful book

[deleted] | [deleted]

Fiancée loses engagement ring, Man refuses to give heirloom ring - NTA

CorrosiveAlkonost | CorrosiveAlkonost

NTA. Losing a $4k ring down an elevator shaft? Nope. 🤷‍♂️

chandler-bingaling | chandler-bingaling

Savage response to fiancée's entitlement and sister's interference 👏

[deleted] | [deleted]

Sentimental jewelry should be taken care of. NTA for holding back.

thatcrazyanimallady | thatcrazyanimallady

Priceless heirloom > $4K engagement ring 💍💰 NTA

[deleted] | [deleted]

Finding lost items in elevator shafts is common 🤷‍♂️. Keeping family heirloom ring is justified 👍

gayasme | gayasme

Engaged Redditor questions how fiancée lost engagement ring. NTA.

endlessotter | endlessotter

Keeping the family heirloom safe is a priority, NTA.

Few_Story3588 | Few_Story3588

Ring is yours to give, don't give it to someone irresponsible 💍

goketchumall | goketchumall

Family ring saved from elevator shaft, NTA for not giving it

Lotex_Style | Lotex_Style

Family heirloom ring goes to women in my family. NTA.

OpinionatedAussie | OpinionatedAussie

Losing a $4,000 ring? You can't blame him. 🤷‍♂️

IJN-Maya202 | IJN-Maya202

Fiancée loses engagement ring, demands family heirloom, NTA refuses 💍

little-lady- | little-lady-

Fiancée lost engagement ring, refuses to give her family heirloom ring. NTA.

Flippn_Freddy | Flippn_Freddy

Fiancée loses $4k ring, demands family heirloom ring. NTA stands firm. 💍

indi50 | indi50

Fiancée loses engagement ring, wants family heirloom instead. Redditors support NTA.

mrsshmenkmen | mrsshmenkmen

Girlfriend loses $4K ring, commenter supports NTA refusing heirloom ring

Own_Experience863 | Own_Experience863

Supportive comment urges OP not to give in to fiancée's guilt.

AlwaysAlexi777 | AlwaysAlexi777

Questioning the engagement? 🤔

Whatever2030 | Whatever2030

Fiancée loses engagement ring, partner keeps family heirloom: NTA 👍

Marmaladeanddryice | Marmaladeanddryice

Man defends decision not to give family heirloom after fiancee loses 4K ring 😬

tomtomclubthumb | tomtomclubthumb

Fiancée lost $4K engagement ring, heirloom ring should stay safe. NTA

candles_0904 | candles_0904

Fiancée loses $4K engagement ring, NTA for not giving heirloom ring

redditposter-- | redditposter--

Woman loses engagement ring, expects heirloom. NTA for OP.

3340bronqen | 3340bronqen

NAH verdict, with a touch of self-deprecating humor 😅

koshka42 | koshka42

Losing precious jewelry before, NTA understands the fiance's decision 👍

mycrookedwang | mycrookedwang

Humorous reply to lost engagement ring. No replies.

Laughingfoxcreates | Laughingfoxcreates

Family jewelry is sacred and should be passed down generations 💍

Ok_Policy_1745 | Ok_Policy_1745

Accepting the loss of an heirloom is tough. NTA.

G_dog_1973 | G_dog_1973

Filed Under: