Boyfriend Proposes With Girlfriend's Lost Heirloom Ring - Romantic or Rude? 🤔💎

Diply Social Team
Diply | Diply

Get ready for a rollercoaster ride of love, loss, and a touch of mystery! 💕😢🔍 This story is about a man head over heels for his girlfriend, ready to take the next big step. But fate throws a curveball when a cherished ring goes missing. 💍😱 Join us as we unravel this tale of a lost heirloom, a secret search party, and a proposal plan that might just be too good to be true. 🕵️‍♀️💒 Will this hopeless romantic's grand gesture backfire or will love conquer all? 🤔❤️ Let's dive in and find out!

🌟 A Love Story for the Ages 💕

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

💍 Ready to Pop the Question 😍

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

😢 Tragedy Strikes: Grandma's Passing 👵

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

💍 The Lost Ring Mystery 🕵️‍♀️

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

💔 The Heartbreak Continues 😭

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

🎄 Christmas Tears and a Brilliant Idea 💡

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

🔍 The Search Party Assembles 🚨

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

👨‍👩‍👧 Family Joins the Hunt 🔎

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

💒 The Big Day Approaches 📅

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

🗣️ Friends Raise Concerns 😕

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

💍 The Amethyst Anxiety-Buster 💜

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

🤔 Is It Really an A-Hole Move? 🧐

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

😰 Doubts Creep In 😬

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

🤷‍♂️ WIBTA? 🙏

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

📝 EDIT: Overwhelming Response! 🌊

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

💍 The Compromise: Ring Shopping Later 🛍️

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

😲 The Surprise Factor 🎉

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

🆕 EDIT2: Insults and Accusations Flying 🤬

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

😮 Surprise Verdict: NTA! 🙌

empty_fondant_9586 | empty_fondant_9586

💍 The Lost Ring Dilemma: A Proposal on the Rocks? 😰

Well, well, well... looks like we've got ourselves a real pickle here! 🥒😅 Our lovestruck hero thought he had the perfect plan: propose with his girlfriend's beloved grandma's ring. 💍👵 But his friends had other ideas, calling him a cheapskate and warning of tainted meanings. 🗣️😬 Now he's second-guessing everything, worried he might come off as a total a-hole. 😰 Will his sentimental gesture be seen as sweet or just plain stingy? 🤔💸 The internet has some strong opinions, that's for sure! 🌐🗣️ Some think it's a touching tribute, others are grabbing their pitchforks. 😇🔱 Let's see what the masses have to say about this unconventional proposal! 👀🍿

A considerate proposal idea for ring shopping together. 😊💍

sickofdriving007 | sickofdriving007

Thoughtful boyfriend finds lost heirloom ring before proposing. ❤

ATadQuirky | ATadQuirky

Regifting a lost heirloom ring for proposal? NAH or NTA?

domatesx | domatesx

Returning the ring might be the safe bet 😜

phiwong | phiwong

Proposing with lost heirloom ring - romantic or rude? Soft YTA

DelurkingtoComment | DelurkingtoComment

Girlfriend's lost heirloom ring re-proposal: romantic or rude? YTA.

Jemma_2 | Jemma_2

Finding the lost ring was sweet, but proposing with it? 😐

chicagoman9876 | chicagoman9876

A thoughtful proposal with an option for a new ring 💍

FoolMe1nceShameOnU | FoolMe1nceShameOnU

Lost heirloom or engagement ring? YTA needs to return it 💎

thirdtryisthecharm | thirdtryisthecharm

User calls out rude proposal with lost heirloom ring.

musical_spork | musical_spork

Returning a lost ring as an engagement ring? Yikes, YWBTA 😱

lihzee | lihzee

Proposing with her lost heirloom ring- YTA or romantic? YTA says a comment.

slumberingGnome | slumberingGnome

Proposal with lost heirloom ring - YTA says commenter.

sjohnson7645 | sjohnson7645

Discussion of engagement ring etiquette and communication with partners.

Usrname52 | Usrname52

Boyfriend's proposal with lost ring - romantic or rude? YTA move.

wannabyte | wannabyte

Respect her grandmother's memory and get a different ring 🙏

Every_Spread_5086 | Every_Spread_5086

Return the ring and propose with a different one instead. 🚫

DZHMMM | DZHMMM

Proposal with lost ring: romantic or rude? Hear opinions 🤔

LacBryn | LacBryn

Sensible advice on engagement ring choice. Be flexible, good luck!

ADG1983 | ADG1983

Suggest telling her now, it might backfire as a surprise 😔

kat_Folland | kat_Folland

Proposing with girlfriend's lost heirloom ring - sentimental or insensitive?💎

poodle_kitten | poodle_kitten

Timing and honesty are key in proposal with lost heirloom ring. 💍

youdidwhatnow10 | youdidwhatnow10

Using grandma's ring as your engagement ring- YTA move 👎

pauliewotsit | pauliewotsit

Propose with the heirloom ring & discuss a new one later 💍

commenter23450 | commenter23450

Proposal with lost heirloom ring - romantic or rude? Soft YTA

PoetSufficient7299 | PoetSufficient7299

Return the ring and talk about proposals with your girlfriend. 💎💍

the_divine_sara | the_divine_sara

Proposal with lost heirloom ring - romantic or rude? YWBTA.

[deleted] | [deleted]

User thinks proposing with girlfriend's lost heirloom ring is YTA.

Boredread | Boredread

Using a lost heirloom ring for an engagement proposal? YTA. 💍

RandomSleepyPanda | RandomSleepyPanda

Proposing with lost heirloom ring - romantic or rude? NAH.

N7twitch | N7twitch

Proposing with lost heirloom ring: Ask the gf's opinion first ❤️

LunaRivera | LunaRivera

Proposal fail - YTA. Give back her grandmother's ring ❌

SuperLoris | SuperLoris

Using girlfriend's lost heirloom ring to propose is tacky - YTA 😑

geidy252 | geidy252

Reusing girlfriend's lost heirloom ring for proposal: thoughtful or tactless? 😕

[deleted] | [deleted]

Engagement ring is a gift, YTA for giving her own property 😑

Sparky-Malarky | Sparky-Malarky

Proposal with lost ring: NTA but could backfire 😕

rhinosorcery | rhinosorcery

User advises against using girlfriend's lost heirloom ring for proposal 🚫

ChewableRobots | ChewableRobots

Using girlfriend's lost ring for proposal - Sweet or strange? 😔

FourLeafClover0 | FourLeafClover0

Suggests giving grandmother's ring as gift before proposing. Good advice! 👍

[deleted] | [deleted]

Proposing with lost heirloom ring but giving option to shop. 💍

PumpkinWrangler | PumpkinWrangler

Keeping a lost heirloom ring to propose? YTA according to comments.

OurLadyOfCygnets | OurLadyOfCygnets

Finding and returning her ring - romantic or just practical? 💎

rosamamoas | rosamamoas

Software YTA suggests proposing with a different ring. NAH or ESH?

LucyLovesApples | LucyLovesApples

Proposing with her grandma's ring - romantic or rude? YWBTA

clover6669 | clover6669

Return the ring and propose again, but together this time 💍

Betrayed_Orphan | Betrayed_Orphan

Proposing with lost heirloom ring: misguided or romantic gesture? 😔

ljw917 | ljw917

Lost ring returned as engagement ring: YTA or romantic gesture?

bookshelfie | bookshelfie

Proposing with girlfriend's lost ring - dumb move or romantic? 😕

SundaColugoToffee | SundaColugoToffee

Ring return if rejected? Risky proposal move 😱

2cat1bird | 2cat1bird

Give it back and buy her an actual engagement ring. YTA.

WelcomeToKittenTown | WelcomeToKittenTown

Proposal with lost heirloom ring - replace or keep sentiment?

MysteriousStaff3388 | MysteriousStaff3388

Romantic proposal with lost heirloom ring, discuss buying additional ring.

RubY-F0x | RubY-F0x

Found ring but kept it for proposal - romantic or rude? NAH

missveronicaleigh | missveronicaleigh

Proposal with lost heirloom ring: romantic or rude? Opinion split 😐

[deleted] | [deleted]

Lost heirloom ring used for surprise proposal - romantic or rude? 😳

The-Moocat | The-Moocat

Romantic gesture or rude move? Commenter says NAH, as long as she's happy.

[deleted] | [deleted]

A considerate proposal involves giving the option of an heirloom ring 💍

[deleted] | [deleted]

Proposal with lost ring - NTA, but preface it right 💎

Mr_Ham_Man80 | Mr_Ham_Man80

Lost heirloom ring found and used in a romantic proposal ❤️

cschmidtusa | cschmidtusa

Proposal with lost ring: NTA, but propose with a new ring.

GoldenAlexanders | GoldenAlexanders

Proposing with lost heirloom ring - NTA. Symbolism matters ❤️💍

SpookyArmadillo | SpookyArmadillo

Let her decide if she wants to change the meaning 😊

captainkaiju | captainkaiju

Reuniting her with her grandmother's ring was a wonderful gesture 😍

georgiajl38 | georgiajl38

Giving girlfriend's lost ring back and proposing separately is better 💍

Character_Theme_8351 | Character_Theme_8351

Giving back lost ring as part of proposal may backfire 😮

stdnormaldeviant | stdnormaldeviant

NTA. Sweet gesture, family rings make the best engagement rings. 👍

Issyswe | Issyswe

Suggests getting a different ring to preserve family heirloom 👍

throw_whey_protein | throw_whey_protein

Having a backup plan for the proposal is thoughtful. 💍❤️

[deleted] | [deleted]

A sweet proposal with a sentimental touch and a shopping spree 😍

ChefMimsy | ChefMimsy

Suggests returning heirloom ring separately and offering custom engagement ring 💍

Smudgikins | Smudgikins

Funny comment on checking for inscriptions on heirloom ring.

[deleted] | [deleted]

Suggests a creative way to propose with heirloom ring and new ring ❤️

Osherono | Osherono

Unique proposal idea - use the lost ring as an excuse 💍

Tephlon | Tephlon

Using her lost heirloom ring to propose? I'd be pissed too! 😠

helpabishout | helpabishout

Proposal should be about the engagement, not finding grandma's ring. 💎

Phil_PhilConners | Phil_PhilConners

Proposal with lost heirloom ring: YTA according to commenters.

[deleted] | [deleted]

Giving girlfriend her own lost ring? YTA, terrible idea 🤨

cattt8678 | cattt8678

Is proposing with a lost heirloom ring romantic or risky? 😱

Constant-Sky-1495 | Constant-Sky-1495

Proposal with girlfriend's heirloom ring - thoughtful or thoughtless? 😕

seamless_whore | seamless_whore

Proposal with lost heirloom ring: Soft YTA, give ASAP & don't connect it to you. 😊

HoneyMCMLXXIII | HoneyMCMLXXIII

Consider telling her ring shopping is non-negotiable and heirloom ring a bonus 💎

Saltyfishfillet | Saltyfishfillet

Proposal on a lost heirloom ring can taint a special day 😢

fleaahh | fleaahh

Proposing with her lost ring is romantic and thoughtful ❤️💍

skater_eli | skater_eli

Love is in the strand! A romantic proposal without a ring.

KirkPicard | KirkPicard

Proposing with lost heirloom ring: Soft YTA but not cheap 💎

ToadtheGreat21 | ToadtheGreat21

Gifting someone their lost ring as proposal - selfish or romantic? 😐

uuuumno | uuuumno

Proposing with lost heirloom ring: thoughtful or tacky? NTA.

vodka_philosophy | vodka_philosophy

Sentimental ring reuse sparks support for NTA comment

Agitated-Routine4060 | Agitated-Routine4060

Filed Under: