Entitled Friend REFUSES to Replace $175 Whisky He Destroyed! 💸🚫

Diply Social Team
Diply | Diply

Picture this: you're hosting your annual Oscar watch party, a tradition that you and your friends absolutely adore. You dress up, place bets on the winners, and munch on popcorn while enjoying the glitz and glamour of Hollywood's biggest night. 🎬 But then, there's a hiccup. Your friend, whom we'll call 'Rick the Wreck,' accidentally breaks an expensive bottle of whisky that your wife was saving for a special occasion. 🥃💥 What's worse? He doesn't plan on replacing it. As the next Oscar party approaches, you're left wondering if you're being too harsh by uninviting him over this 'drunken mistake.' 🤔 Let's dive into this dramatic tale and see what unfolds...

🎉 Oscar Party Tradition 🎉

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

👗 Dressing Up & Betting 🍿

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🥃 Whisky Loving Wife & The Gift 🎁

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

👶 New Baby & Saving the Bottle 🍼

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🥴 Rick's Drunken Mishap 😵

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🙏 Apologies & Forgiveness 💔

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

💸 The Money Talk 🤔

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

💰 Rick's Financial Struggles 😟

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

⏳ Deadline & Saving Up 📅

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🔍 Checking In on Rick's Progress 📈

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

😬 The Truth Comes Out 🚫

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🚪 Uninvited & Angry 😡

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🤷‍♂️ Entitled or Unsympathetic? 🧐

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

⏰ Time's Running Out 😖

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🍸 Party Details & Rick's Actions 🚶‍♂️

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🔍 Rick's Sneaky Cabinet Raid 🍾

InternationalList333 | InternationalList333

🏆 Oscar Party Drama: Whisky Woes & Broken Promises 🍿

Our protagonist and his wife, Kate, love hosting their annual Oscar watch party. But last year, their friend 'Rick the Wreck' got wasted and accidentally broke a pricey bottle of whisky that Kate was saving. 😵💔 Rick apologized, but when asked about replacing the bottle, he claimed he couldn't afford it due to his financial struggles. 😟 Our protagonist gave him a deadline: save up for a new bottle by this year's party, or he's uninvited. Rick agreed, but ultimately failed to save any money. 🚫💰 So, our protagonist kept his promise and uninvited him. Now, Rick and his girlfriend are furious, accusing our protagonist of being unsympathetic and entitled. 😡 With the party just around the corner, our protagonist is starting to feel guilty. Is he being too harsh, or is he justified in his actions? 🤷‍♂️ Let's see what the internet thinks of this situation...

Friendship over money? A good friend is worth forgiving 🤝

rafaelvandercan | rafaelvandercan

Basic guest etiquette: if you break something, make it right.

7hr0wn | 7hr0wn

A thoughtful analysis of the situation and the friend's responsibility. 👍

mfruitfly | mfruitfly

Replacing the whiskey may not be worth losing a friend. 🤷‍♂️

thumpmyponcho | thumpmyponcho

User calls out both parties for AH behavior over whisky 😠

MonsieurWobble | MonsieurWobble

ESH: Poor apology and hounding over bottle, but accidents happen.

here4judgment | here4judgment

Friend breaks whisky bottle, refuses to replace. NTA suggests alternatives.

apinchofginger_ | apinchofginger_

Accidents happen, but is $175 worth losing a friendship? 🤔

RHND2020 | RHND2020

Friend destroys $175 whiskey, refuses to replace it. Obligation issues?

jimmer674 | jimmer674

Is forgiveness enough or should he replace the whisky? 🤔

RenaissanceMomm | RenaissanceMomm

Chill out, it's just whiskey. Friendship > material possessions 👍

GazelleIll495 | GazelleIll495

Is a $175 bottle of whiskey worth ending a friendship? 🤔

Kind_Bet9556 | Kind_Bet9556

Uncomfortable confrontation over whiskey leads to ESH judgement. 👎

shillingforshecrets | shillingforshecrets

Defending an accused friend, but is OP an alcoholic?

drumnamona | drumnamona

Replacing a broken item is classy, but don't torpedo relationships.

mp29k | mp29k

No true friend would refuse to replace destroyed $175 whisky 💸

Antelope_31 | Antelope_31

ESH for confusing forgiveness and demanding payment, he for lying.

ItemInternational26 | ItemInternational26

Friend accidentally broke whisky, OP being unreasonable about compensation 🤷🏻‍♂️

NachoAverageNacho7 | NachoAverageNacho7

No excuse for not replacing the whisky. NTA.

Apart-Ad-6518 | Apart-Ad-6518

Friend gets drunk, breaks whisky, lies and calls OP entitled 😡

Dogmother123 | Dogmother123

Destroying private property at a party? NTA, cut ties. 💸

ammyterra | ammyterra

Letting go of the whiskey might save the friendship. 🤷‍♂️

Small-Statement5295 | Small-Statement5295

Bad friend got drunk, destroyed property, lied and refused replacement. NTA.

FuzzyMom2005 | FuzzyMom2005

YTA, it's just a bottle of whiskey. Learn to forgive.

Camera-Realistic | Camera-Realistic

Friendship over a $175 whiskey? YTA according to comments.

Distinct-Shoe5448 | Distinct-Shoe5448

Friend can't afford to replace whiskey, worth more than friendship?

Jezabel8708 | Jezabel8708

Friend breaks $175 whiskey gift and refuses to replace it, NTA.

Baked_Tinker | Baked_Tinker

Friendship or money? The eternal dilemma 🤔

GalloMachisimo | GalloMachisimo

Uninviting friend after destroying $175 whisky: NTA consequences.

StAlvis | StAlvis

Concerned commenter wonders if friend has alcohol problem 🤔

cryssylee90 | cryssylee90

Clever response to entitled friend's 'drunk me' excuse. 🥃👀

Bureaucratic_Dick | Bureaucratic_Dick

Mixed feelings about the situation and forgiveness, but friend's actions questionable 🤔

fegd | fegd

Responsible host rightfully holds careless friend accountable for whisky. 🥃

ariesgal11 | ariesgal11

Friendship over whiskey? YTA according to this comment.


Hosting parties? Move valuables upstairs to avoid breakages. ESH situation.

Haytham_Ken | Haytham_Ken

Friend broke whiskey, OP's reaction seems over the top. YTA.

laughterwards | laughterwards

Friendship over materialism, YTA for valuing whisky over friend 🚫

phloralphancy | phloralphancy

Considerate perspective on replacing destroyed item based on financial situation 👍

Humble_Scarcity1195 | Humble_Scarcity1195

Debate on whether OP is the a**hole for expecting compensation.

Janie_Canuck | Janie_Canuck

Friendship over material things. YTA - Strange hill to die on. 🚫

Acceptable_Pay_7647 | Acceptable_Pay_7647

OP's attitude towards friend may have consequences on future parties. 🤔

Gatodeluna | Gatodeluna

Friend breaks $175 whisky, now $ or friendship? Compassionate reply.

Classic_Complex_2602 | Classic_Complex_2602

Guest accidentally broke whisky bottle at party, OP is TA.

ClarityByHilarity | ClarityByHilarity

Friend destroys $175 whisky, had a year to save. NTA.

1000thatbeyotch | 1000thatbeyotch

Being drunk is not an excuse. NTA. Rick should pay up. 💸

Cei-U | Cei-U

Friends should take responsibility for damage caused at parties. ESH 🤷🏼‍♂️

Secondwavealert | Secondwavealert

To forgive or not to forgive? That is the question.

SensualSideburnTrim | SensualSideburnTrim

User accuses couple of loan sharking friend for whisky replacement. ESH 🤬

Transmit_Him | Transmit_Him

Financial hardship can affect judgment in friendships. 🤷‍♀️

Mindless-Compote-388 | Mindless-Compote-388

Friend refuses to replace broken whisky and insults couple. NTA.

trishsf | trishsf

Friend breaks whisky, refuses to replace. NTA says community.

legallymyself | legallymyself

Friend breaks expensive whiskey, won't replace it. Duck that guy.

TFeary1992 | TFeary1992

Respect the host's property and ask for more booze, NTA.

JGCii | JGCii

Mixed opinions on cutting off entitled friend over destroyed whiskey.

Traditional_Let_1823 | Traditional_Let_1823

Friendship > Whisky: Set boundaries, offer cheap whisky instead 👍

headhurt21 | headhurt21

Both parties acted poorly, but neither is a total a**hole. 😐

basroil | basroil

Friendship over drinks ruined by $175 whiskey drama. YTA.

Phillip_htx | Phillip_htx

Engaging discussion on whisky storage and responsibility.

Loud_Low_9846 | Loud_Low_9846

Friendship over $200 whiskey? ESH but not worth it 🚫

Loydx | Loydx

Being poor doesn't excuse being irresponsible and a liar. 👍

Zilla197737 | Zilla197737

Is friendship worth more than a $175 whisky bottle? 🤔

TijayesPJs442 | TijayesPJs442

Guest should have offered to replace the bottle eventually. ESH.

brishen_is_on | brishen_is_on

Mixed feelings on judgement, suggests payment plan instead of replacement.

Newdaytoday1215 | Newdaytoday1215

Defending the friend's mistake and valuing friendship over whiskey. 🙏

hits_riders_soak | hits_riders_soak

Poster questions the double standards of some commenters. NTA.

Ilikeliamneeson | Ilikeliamneeson

Gray area on whether friend is NTA or verging on AH

EngineeringCockney | EngineeringCockney

Entitled friend breaks $175 whisky, NTA for not inviting back. 👍

cordelia1955 | cordelia1955

Hold him accountable! NTA for expecting Rick to replace whisky 👏

GothicEnchantrix | GothicEnchantrix

Being reasonable and understanding can avoid serious trouble 👍

Zoeloumoo | Zoeloumoo

Friendship > Whiskey: Commenter calls out entitlement and privilege. 👏

Cabrundit | Cabrundit

Is a bottle of whisky worth losing a friend? 🤔

Confusedbox | Confusedbox

Setting boundaries with entitled friend who won't replace whisky 💸

billionaireXtinction | billionaireXtinction

Demand accountability for sentimental gifts. Uninvite until replaced. 💸

Discount_Mithral | Discount_Mithral

Friend breaks whisky, refuses to replace. NTA stands their ground.


Guest ruins expensive whiskey, refuses to pay. NTA for consequences.

Fuzzy_Biscotti_7959 | Fuzzy_Biscotti_7959

Friend owes $175 for destroyed whisky but don't hound him.

HornsUp115 | HornsUp115

Friend lies and refuses to replace destroyed whisky. NTA.

Ok_Boat_1243 | Ok_Boat_1243

Friend breaks whisky, refuses to replace. NTA calls out.

caryn1477 | caryn1477

Replace the whisky for your wife, don't wait for friend. NTA 👍

Inlowerorbit | Inlowerorbit

Being drunk doesn't excuse responsibility. NTA for rescinding invitation.

RocMills | RocMills

Forgiving or foolish? Debate over damaged $175 whisky 🥃

missannthrope1 | missannthrope1

Friend accidentally broke $175 whisky, YTA if broke, NTA if not. Suggests creative repayment plan. 🤔

Bubbafett33 | Bubbafett33

Both parties share the blame 👀 But uninviting was fair.

Plumbus-aficianado | Plumbus-aficianado

Take responsibility, forgive the friend, lock up valuables. 🍸

imtchogirl | imtchogirl

Filed Under: