Daughter Steals Sister's Dog? 🐶😲 Family Torn Apart!

Diply Social Team
Diply | Diply

Meet a family of five, including three daughters - Phoebe (21), Maddie (18), and Lily (16). The youngest, Lily, has a history of being spoiled by her dad, which has caused some tension within the family. The latest drama? A dog named Charlie, who was initially brought home for Lily, but ended up being cared for by Phoebe. Now that Phoebe is moving out, she wants to take Charlie with her, but Lily isn't having it. Let's dive into this canine custody battle! 🐕🥊

The Spoiled Sister 🛍️

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Lily's Doggy Desire 🐶

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Charlie the Pomchi Arrives 🐾

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

From Dog Lover to Cat Lady 🐕➡️🐈

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Charlie Left Out in the Cold 🥶

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Phoebe Steps In 💕

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Work Buddy 🏢🐶

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Phoebe's Moving Plans 🚚

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Charlie's New Home? 🏠

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

The Ideal Setup 🌟

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Mom's Approval 👍

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Lily's Fury 😡

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Doggy Drama 🐕💥

aitadogcustody | aitadogcustody

Canine Custody Chaos! 🐶🏛️

So here we have a family divided over a lovable pomchi named Charlie. Phoebe, the oldest sister, has been the primary caretaker for the dog, even though he was initially brought home for Lily. Now that Phoebe is moving out, she wants to take Charlie with her, but Lily and her dad are putting up a fight. Who do you think should get custody of Charlie? Let's see what the internet has to say about this messy situation.

Neglected dog leads to family feud. NTA for confronting daughter.

FunkyOrangePenguin | FunkyOrangePenguin

Teaching responsibility to entitled sister. 🐶😲

NomNom83WasTaken | NomNom83WasTaken

Two-year caretaker deserves the dog, not a pampered princess 🐶

pfashby | pfashby

Dog-napping sister deemed NTA, but must pay back sister. 🐶

MisachuHawke | MisachuHawke

Daughter gives up claim to dog, comment suggests enrichment options. 🐶

dublos | dublos

Husband's spoiling sets daughter up for failure. 🤦‍♀️

Spank_Cakes | Spank_Cakes

Dog custody battle: YTA if you take responsibility from daughter.

pjeans | pjeans

NTA stands up for sister's rights to dog after neglect.

murphy2345678 | murphy2345678

Dog ownership responsibility debated in family dispute. 🐶

Savings_Ice_5856 | Savings_Ice_5856

Dog thief gets what she deserves. Justice served 👏

SadWinnipeger | SadWinnipeger

Phoebe is NTA for taking care of Charlie, Lily needs wake-up call 🐶

throwawaynoise97 | throwawaynoise97

Teachable moment for disrespectful sister stealing pet parent's dog. 🐶

Live-Elderberry-3780 | Live-Elderberry-3780

Daughter and husband problem? Take revenge on dog walking.

Infamous_Control_778 | Infamous_Control_778

NTA stands firm on daughter's dog-stealing, sets boundaries. 🐶

EmeraldBlueZen | EmeraldBlueZen

Oldest daughter should take dog, 16yo needs to learn responsibility 💼

Particular_Elk3022 | Particular_Elk3022

Parenting favoritism creates entitled child who steals sister's dog. NTA wins.

moew4974 | moew4974

Husband's mistake? NTA for not wanting to take care of pet 🐶

LadyRosy | LadyRosy

NTA suggests making Lily responsible for Charlie's care and expenses.

alreadyovereacting | alreadyovereacting

Oldest sister should take the dog for its well-being 🐶

ultimovice | ultimovice

Choosing Charlie's well-being over Lily's tantrum. 🐶😲

000-Hotaru_Tomoe | 000-Hotaru_Tomoe

ESH, poor communication skills led to dog ownership dilemma 🐶

herdingcats2020 | herdingcats2020

Dog gone drama: Commenter supports daughter's right to take pet.

TN_perverted_ff | TN_perverted_ff

Phoebe rightfully keeps the dog. NTA. 🐶❤️

Aylauria | Aylauria

Dog ownership debate: who cares for it best? #NTA

[deleted] | [deleted]

Phoebe is the real pet owner here 🐶. NTA.

Street_Passage_1151 | Street_Passage_1151

Animal welfare comes first. NTA made the right call. 🐶

Material-Profit5923 | Material-Profit5923

Husband's double standard on pet decisions. NTA, husband is.

My_Panache | My_Panache

Responsibility over possession. Important lesson for all pet owners. 🐶

candycoatedcoward | candycoatedcoward

NTA, but dad's behavior needs to be addressed for kids' sake 👍

giantbrownguy | giantbrownguy

Dog vs cat debate. NTA suggests Lily should be grateful. 🐶🌙

Whats_Up_Coconut | Whats_Up_Coconut

Daughter neglects dog, sister takes it. NTA verdict.


Chronic illness and sister's neglect lead to puppy favoritism. 🐶

LuckyInLove8789 | LuckyInLove8789

Communication is key, husband should deal with spoiled brat 👍

themoonismybestie | themoonismybestie

Quiz time for Lily: When did you last take care of dog? NTA

TheOneAndOnlySelf | TheOneAndOnlySelf

Family drama over dog custody. NTA stands up for fairness.

Quiet_Goat8086 | Quiet_Goat8086

NTA but husband favors sister over daughters and their dog 🐶

astrocanyounaut | astrocanyounaut

Advice on parenting and preventing sibling rivalry. 👨🏻‍👩🏻👥

[deleted] | [deleted]

Daughter's dog favoritism causes family feud. NTA comment.

Flat_Librarian_1724 | Flat_Librarian_1724

Sister steals dog, but is she the a**hole? No, NTA.

sci_fi_bi | sci_fi_bi

Putting dog's quality of life first 🐶👏

JanetInSpain | JanetInSpain

Taking a stand for a stolen dog. NTA wins.

InfectedAlloy88 | InfectedAlloy88

NTA defends Phoebe's ownership of neglected dog with financial logic.

NerdySwampWitch40 | NerdySwampWitch40

Sister steals dog, but NTA for making her pay expenses. 🐶

Consistent_Ad_805 | Consistent_Ad_805

Protecting the pup from spoiled brats. NTA.

NorthwestPassenger | NorthwestPassenger

Daughter's negligence leads to family pet custody dispute. 🐶

PrestigiousWedding36 | PrestigiousWedding36

Choosing the right home for Charlie 🐶. NTA's advice.

HandfulOfEarth | HandfulOfEarth

Fair solution proposed for dog ownership dispute 🐶

NowWithMoreChocolate | NowWithMoreChocolate

Dog custody battle pits sisters against each other. NTA wins.

Maleficent_Ad407 | Maleficent_Ad407

User calls out family members for enabling entitled behavior. 🤨


Dog's emotional attachment to humans. NTA for not separating them.

ComprehensiveBand586 | ComprehensiveBand586

Daughter steals sister's dog, but commenter supports her decision. NTA 🐶

[deleted] | [deleted]

Dog custody battle divides family. NTA stands firm.

Kooky-Today-3172 | Kooky-Today-3172

Neglectful daughter loses dog to responsible caretaker. Tough love needed. 🐶

az22hctac | az22hctac

Abandoned dog ownership debated. NTA or YTA? 🐶

Knife-yWife-y | Knife-yWife-y

Dog ownership becomes a family feud. NTA comment sparks debate.

JCBashBash | JCBashBash

NTA for valuing the dog's feelings over sister's selfishness. Concerned about husband's impact on daughter.

Working-Caterpillar | Working-Caterpillar

Phoebe should take care of Charlie, Lily wants control. NTA.

Huge_Industry_1259 | Huge_Industry_1259

Comparing responsibilities may bring clarity in dog ownership dispute. 🐶

Historical_Carpet262 | Historical_Carpet262

Neglected dog leads to family feud. NTA for keeping pet.

Ok-Mode-2038 | Ok-Mode-2038

Spouse needs to support decision to give dog to responsible owner 🐶

Dizzy_Emotion7381 | Dizzy_Emotion7381

Husband's terrible parenting causing family chaos. NTA.

[deleted] | [deleted]

Sibling rivalry over a dog 🐶 NTA calls out selfish behavior

rczinna | rczinna

Parent stands up to entitled stepchild. NTA wins the day!

[deleted] | [deleted]

Daughter neglected dog, commenter changes from YTA to NTA.

Pizza-love | Pizza-love

Husband causing family tension over dog ownership. NTA.

LillyLing10 | LillyLing10

Sibling rivalry resolved with love for family cat 🐱

Popular_Emu1723 | Popular_Emu1723

Dog drama: Abandoned pup bonds with new owner, causing family rift.

MumSquared | MumSquared

Phoebe deserves the dog, hubby needs to treat kids equally. 🐶

bkwormtricia | bkwormtricia

NTA. Phoebe now has the dog. What about the sister?

Lunarisles | Lunarisles

Sibling rivalry turns ugly over ownership of neglected dog. 🐶

Sidneyreb | Sidneyreb

Divorce over a dog? NTA takes drastic measures. 🐶

rickallen71 | rickallen71

NTA, but family dynamics and tough love needed 👍

beefytaint21 | beefytaint21

Neglected dog leads to family feud 🐶 NTA for sister

Time-Tie-231 | Time-Tie-231

NTA chooses caretaker over irresponsible sister for beloved Charlie 🐶

Chaoticgood790 | Chaoticgood790

Charlie deserves love and care. Lilly's priorities are questionable.

Terrible-Owl-76 | Terrible-Owl-76

Filed Under: