Woman Asks Sister And BIL To Move Out After 3 Years Of Supporting Them Following Family Tragedy

Two women talking while on a balcony.
Unsplash | kevin laminto

What would you do if you offered your home to your sister and BIL after a horrific family tragedy, and they still haven't left three years later? A woman posted on AITA, seeking advice after she asked her sister and BIL to move out before getting married and starting a family. She has been supporting them financially and emotionally ever since the tragedy, and her fiancé is growing increasingly frustrated with the situation.

The woman tried dropping hints but finally had to tell her sister straight up that she needed her house back. However, her sister got upset and called her an a**hole for not considering her feelings.

Was the woman in the wrong for asking them to leave after three years?

Heartbreaking tragedy leaves sister and BIL dependent for 3 years

dearlyohwow | dearlyohwow

Woman supports sister and BIL after tragedy but asks them to move out

dearlyohwow | dearlyohwow

Supporting family after tragedy - Boundaries and self-care matter 🙏

dearlyohwow | dearlyohwow

Fiancé frustrated with sister and BIL taking advantage of OP's generosity 💰

dearlyohwow | dearlyohwow

Woman asks sister and BIL to move out after 3 years.

dearlyohwow | dearlyohwow

Sister agrees to leave after emotional talk with homeowner

dearlyohwow | dearlyohwow

Woman asks sister and BIL to move out after 3 years 🏠

After supporting her sister and brother-in-law for three years following a tragic accident that claimed the lives of their three young children, a woman has decided to ask them to move out. Despite being emotionally and financially supportive, the woman has grown frustrated with their refusal to seek therapy and find work.

With her upcoming marriage and desire to start a family of her own, she has decided to take a stand and ask for her house back. However, this decision has caused tension and hurt feelings in the family.

Read on to find out how others have reacted to the woman's request in this situation and whether or not she is in the wrong.

NTA. Three years is a long time. It's time for them to go.


It's been 3 years. What are their plans? 🤔

[deleted] | [deleted]

NTA for wanting to live alone with your fiancé. 🙅‍♀️🏠

indignant-loris | indignant-loris

Sister's entitlement causes family feud 👀

SteakMenu | SteakMenu

Setting boundaries is tough, but it's for their own good 💪

ahender8 | ahender8

Encourage therapy for bereaved family and offer support and resources 🙏

MayorCharlesCoulon | MayorCharlesCoulon

Supporting family shouldn't mean delaying your own happiness. 😔

Megmca | Megmca

Even the mom won't take them in. NTA for kicking out.

Tiredmum82 | Tiredmum82

3 years of support, time for sister and BIL to leave 🏡

SereneGoldfish | SereneGoldfish

Encourage grief counseling for BIL and sister. NTA.

nikokazini | nikokazini

NTA OP has been patient and reasonable, and has every right to ask her sister and BIL to move out. It's time for them to support themselves. 💪

fernAlly | fernAlly

NAH, sister and BIL need professional help and empathy 🙏

issy_haatin | issy_haatin

Commenter questions BIL and sister's gratitude for 3 years support.

MaryK007 | MaryK007

Don't let guilt hold you back! You're NTA 🙌

mypreciousssssssss | mypreciousssssssss

You deserve to prioritize your own happiness ❤️👍

Comprehensive-Fun47 | Comprehensive-Fun47

Kindly firm: prioritize your needs and help them move on.

OhmsWay-71 | OhmsWay-71

NTA. Evicting them may be necessary for your own well-being.

AttemptedAdult | AttemptedAdult

After 3 yrs of support, NTA asks sister/BIL to leave 👏

CorgaroniMac | CorgaroniMac

You're NTA for asking them to move out. It's not your responsibility. 👌

toasteemuffin95 | toasteemuffin95

Encourage them to seek help to move forward together 🤝

TheMysticalBaconTree | TheMysticalBaconTree

Time to let go of the crutch 🚶‍♀️🚶‍♂️

merryschmetterling | merryschmetterling

Pushing them out of the nest 🐣 - NTA

evelbug | evelbug

Sister and BIL overstay welcome, NTA suggests mom take over support 👍

[deleted] | [deleted]

Don't be taken advantage of! It's your house! 💪🏠

exmospy19 | exmospy19

NTA for wanting sister and BIL to move out, but insensitive delivery.

JustNoThrowsAway | JustNoThrowsAway

OP's mom can't provide support due to her own grief.

mycatshavehadenough | mycatshavehadenough

Offered kindness, but time limit to it. NTA for wanting home.

AcceptableHome3 | AcceptableHome3

Supportive comment encourages sister to move forward positively ❤️

mm172 | mm172

Compassionate comment encourages moving on post-family tragedy 💛

brainfreeze4445 | brainfreeze4445

After 3 years of support, it's responsible to want space 🤔

Darrenizer | Darrenizer

Setting boundaries is tough, but necessary for everyone's well-being. 💪

QuirkySyrup55947 | QuirkySyrup55947

Empathetic commenters acknowledge the ongoing grief of losing children.

alwayshungry1001 | alwayshungry1001

Direct communication necessary for asking family to move out 😬

hotheadnchickn | hotheadnchickn

Supporting family is tough, but boundaries are necessary. 💪

Primary-Criticism929 | Primary-Criticism929

Don't let them take advantage of your kindness. You're NTA! 🙌

likecommentsurvive | likecommentsurvive

NTA offers sister and BIL a safe place to mourn, but it's time for them to move out and seek therapy. OP also considers their own pain.

BabserellaWT | BabserellaWT

Supportive commenter calls out sister's behavior, suggests alternate solution 💪

Cautious-Blueberry63 | Cautious-Blueberry63

The mystery of what the sister and BIL do all day 🤔

Minimum_Peak9955 | Minimum_Peak9955

Heartfelt empathy for a tough situation. 🙏

MoonlightxRose | MoonlightxRose

Taking advantage of kindness? 🤔 It's time for them to move out! 🏡

happycoffeebean13 | happycoffeebean13

Moving on after tragedy: Setting boundaries is not selfish 🙌

bizianka | bizianka

Supporting family through tragedy is one thing, but freeloaders indefinitely 🤔

Honorable_Lemom | Honorable_Lemom

Enabling family for 3 years, now time to cut off. 💰🚂

Realistic-Airport775 | Realistic-Airport775

Compassion and empathy shine through in tough family situation ❤️

MercurialMagician | MercurialMagician

Time to cut the cord 🗡️. NTA for kicking out.

Working-Kangaroo-639 | Working-Kangaroo-639

Ending dependency after tragedy. NTA for setting boundaries.

Relevant-Position-43 | Relevant-Position-43

Stand your ground! 🙌🏼

Little_Season3410 | Little_Season3410

Compassionate NTA comment validates OP's decision to ask sister to move out 🙏

EnvironmentalLuck515 | EnvironmentalLuck515

Grieving family needs therapy, hard structure and joy in life

Automatic_Value7555 | Automatic_Value7555

Dealing with family tragedy and supporting loved ones is tough 💔

lapsteelguitar | lapsteelguitar

Helping family can sometimes mean making tough decisions. 💪

eatshoney | eatshoney

Supporting family after tragedy, but NTA for boundaries 🙌

Potato_times_potato | Potato_times_potato

Supporting family for 3 years, now sister and BIL out. NTA 👍

Firesquid | Firesquid

Compassionate NTA comment encourages family to confront their grief and move forward 🙏


Compassionate advice for OP on supporting sister and BIL 💛

Mewssbites | Mewssbites

Compassionate comment highlights importance of therapy after family tragedy ❤️

krissttaaa | krissttaaa

Sister and BIL overstayed their welcome, NTA for asking them to leave 🚪

HmnCllTr | HmnCllTr

Misreading the title led to a surprising NTA judgment 😅

sharklings | sharklings

Time to let go: Woman asks sister and BIL to move out

mizfit0416 | mizfit0416