“AITA For Kicking My Sister Out Of Our Family Dinner After She Made A ‘Practical Observation’?”

Alfe Mercado
Go away
Shutterstock | 580987

When Fred and Sarah announced they were expecting, Katie and I kept it to ourselves, but things took an unexpected turn...

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

Family canceling a trip due to baby costs and mom's health leads to a heated dinner

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

Katie's "practical observation" ruffled some feathers and ruined the family dinner!

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

A month after a stillborn baby, brother and SIL devastated and SIL's mental health not well.

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

SIL's "practical observation" caused tension at the family dinner!

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

Katie's "practical observation" sparked a heated debate at the family dinner 🤔

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

Fred's passionate response to Katie's “practical observation” reveals the powerful impact of words.

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

A family dinner gone wrong after a 'practical observation' is met with defensiveness.

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

After making a 'practical observation', Sarah was asked to leave the family dinner, leaving her hurt and angry

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

Drama at the dinner table! Should the OP have kicked out their sister for making a “practical observation”?⁉️

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

Who's in the wrong here? Is it wrong to kick someone out for making a “practical observation”? 🤔

crispsandfries | crispsandfries

A family dinner gone awry. Should the sister have been kicked out?

A sibling confrontation gone wrong. Yesterday, a family dinner hosted by a Reddit user's sibling ended in a dramatic confrontation between the host and their sister Katie. Katie had made an insensitive comment about her brother and sister-in-law's financial situation, which deeply upset the couple. The host quickly intervened and asked the sister to leave, but their parents were shocked and thought that the host had gone too far. The Reddit user asks, was it appropriate for the host to ask their sister to leave? All this and more will be discussed in the comments. Let's dive in!

🤬 NTA: family did well

iryngael | iryngael

💔 NTA: no silver linings for losing a wanted baby

BaltimoreBadger23 | BaltimoreBadger23

OP's practical 👊🏼 response to Katie's 'observation' ✅ NTA 🙅‍♀️

lieunee | lieunee

NTA and 🤯 for Katie

BeccasBump | BeccasBump

Callous comment 🤯

ZookeepergameWise774 | ZookeepergameWise774

🤦🏻‍♀️ Katie's callous comment crosses the line!

Kitchen-Arm-3288 | Kitchen-Arm-3288

NTA 😱 Katie's awful

FrolickingTiggers | FrolickingTiggers

NTA: Katie can 🏃‍♀️

LPOLED | LPOLED

🤬Sister's cruel comment = 🚫family dinner! 🤷‍♀️NTA?

angryomlette | angryomlette

NTA: 🤷‍♂️ 💰 🙅‍♀️

oscillius | oscillius

NTA: 🤦🏻‍♀️ such an insensitive comment!

tastyqilin | tastyqilin

Yikes! 🤢 NTA.

fresh_pickled_toad | fresh_pickled_toad

No a-hole here! 🙅

PeggyHW | PeggyHW

NTA 💯👊 Sister's 'practical observation' was beyond rude!

NerdzillaFTW | NerdzillaFTW

😮👊 NTA for kicking out sis

nerdy_latino | nerdy_latino

NTA: Grieving parent can't be consoled 💔

ExcellentPatience298 | ExcellentPatience298

NTA: Sister's 'practical observation' crossed the line 🛑

Urbanyeti0 | Urbanyeti0

🤬 NTA: Your sister needs to be banned from family functions!

dheffe01 | dheffe01

Is it wrong to be 🤬😡 at a sister's 'practical observation'?

[deleted] | [deleted]

Family dinner gone wrong 🙁

SadderOlderWiser | SadderOlderWiser

Sister's 'practical observation' 🤔

Dunkinbikkies0 | Dunkinbikkies0

NTA - Katie's behavior is inexcusable.

canuck_2022 | canuck_2022

NTA: 💪👊 No apology needed!

dog_star_ | dog_star_

NTA: You were right💯

greenora | greenora

NTA - Mom needs to set her 🔥 🔥 🔥 straight!

ikediggety | ikediggety

🤦‍♂️ NTA: No tact from sister!

ToastAbrikoos | ToastAbrikoos

NTA: 🤬🤬Family needs to stop excusing Katie's callousness🤬🤬

MissTheWire | MissTheWire

NTA for setting boundaries!

s_hinoku | s_hinoku

NTA👏🏼 - a 👮‍♀️ spokesperson for the Uvalde police?

Glum-Communication68 | Glum-Communication68

Sister's 'practical' observation: 😞 NTA 👍

OphrysAlba | OphrysAlba

Entitled people's perspective🤦‍♂️

themini_shit | themini_shit

🤬 An outrageous suggestion

molly_menace | molly_menace

No a-hole here 👏

saucisse | saucisse

🤔 Is there a time for personal choices and basic human empathy?

MaimeM | MaimeM

Sister's 'practical observation' 😳

cantbemeto | cantbemeto

NTA: 🤷‍♀️Can dish out but can't take it!

AsurprisedCantaloupe | AsurprisedCantaloupe

NTA: Katie is a judgmental a-hole 🤬

happybanana134 | happybanana134

NTA - Katie needs to learn a lesson 🤦‍♂️

Repulsive-Ad-8546 | Repulsive-Ad-8546

NTA: Sister makes a selfish 'observation'

Slow_Orange_239 | Slow_Orange_239

NTA: 🚫 bitterness 💭

Dangerous_Mail1939 | Dangerous_Mail1939

NTA for kicking out a 🤬 heartless sister!

DaughterWifeMum | DaughterWifeMum

NTA: sibling vs sibling

domerjohn15 | domerjohn15

NTA: Kindness ≠ practicality,

Still_Association | Still_Association

👿 NTA! Your sister is HIDEOUS 🤬

llc4269 | llc4269

Family drama 😳

AnankeOrganized | AnankeOrganized

Katie's actions cause outrage

truthlady8678 | truthlady8678

NTA: 👊🏼 Unwanted opinions 👋🏼

Kenpatchigo | Kenpatchigo

🤬 NTA for kicking out a guest for an awful comment!

AintShitAunty | AintShitAunty

Family drama: 🏡🤬🤯

GlitteringProfessor1 | GlitteringProfessor1

😡 Not the A-hole 🤔

laurie93 | laurie93

NTA: Katie just 💔

OGablogian | OGablogian

NTA: Sister's 'practical observation' not okay 🤦‍♀️

[deleted] | [deleted]

NTA: Katie couldn't stay 🔥

DynkoFromTheNorth | DynkoFromTheNorth

NTA: Katie was 🚫insensitive and immature

xpotential31 | xpotential31