When a 28-year-old woman decided to use the diamond from her late grandmother’s necklace for her engagement ring, she never expected her mom to be so against the idea. The medical student and her boyfriend are tight on money, and she thought it would be absurd to spend thousands on an engagement ring when they’re not financially stable. But her mom’s reaction was one of heartache and disapproval, believing that the man should be able to provide for his future wife. So, is she in the wrong for wanting to use the heirloom diamond? Let’s dive into the story.
Grandma’s Precious Gift

Tight on Money

A Sensible Solution?

Mom’s Heartache

Deadbeat Boyfriend?

Sentimental Struggles

Edit: Clarifications

Bank Security Deposit Box

Brother’s Engagement Ring

Honoring Grandma’s Love ❤️

Hidden Away

Heirloom Heartache: Who’s Right?
In a heart-wrenching family conflict, a woman’s plan to use her late grandmother’s diamond from a necklace for her engagement ring has left her mom feeling crushed. The mother believes that the man should be able to provide for his future wife and disapproves of her daughter’s decision. With the necklace tucked away in a bank security deposit box, the daughter is left wondering if she’s in the wrong for wanting to honor her grandmother’s love. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…
Get the necklace appraised before dismantling it for an engagement ring

Sentimental commenter suggests alternative gems for engagement rings

Using an heirloom for an engagement ring – sentimental or selfish?

Daughter wants to use late grandma’s diamond for ring. Commenters disagree.

Financial motives for dismantling heirloom, family drama ensues. ESH.

User calls out OP for wanting to destroy family heirloom.

Destroying a family heirloom for a big ass diamond? ESH.

Debate over repurposing late grandma’s jewelry for engagement ring

Commenter calls out OP for being selfish and insensitive

Lab-grown diamonds can look like the real deal for less

Diamonds are forever, but do you really need one?

Debate over repurposing late grandmother’s diamond for engagement ring
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/18670432-8dbb-490d-ba03-0cd8569427a5.png)
Don’t destroy a family heirloom for a diamond ring. Consider alternatives.

Wearing grandma’s diamond as a necklace could be a nice story

Engagement ring debate sparks YTA judgement and life advice ⚖️

Sweet way to remember grandma. NTA for using diamond for ring.

Debate over the meaning of an engagement ring and its significance

NAH. Using grandma’s diamond for ring, but mom upset. Consider finances.

Daughter wants to use grandma’s diamond for ring, mother objects. NAH.

Converting the necklace into a ring is super sweet and thoughtful ❤

Commenter calls out YTA for destroying sentimental necklace
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/97e9e8d0-b95d-4f2a-b8bd-6923280e40ef.png)
NTA/NAH: Mom upset over necklace, but it’s yours to decide

Mom values sentimentality, daughter prioritizes finances. YTA vs NAH.

Daughter wants to use grandma’s jewelry for ring, mom disagrees. NTA.

No AHs here! Understanding comment suggests alternative ring options.

Claim your inheritance, throw it off a boat, NTA!

Repurposing grandma’s diamond for engagement ring is ethical and honorable

Debate over using heirloom for engagement ring sparks financial assumptions.

Engaging and thoughtful advice on using late grandma’s diamond

User calls out OP for dismantling an heirloom for engagement ring

NTA: Repurpose the necklace, keep the memories.

Keeping family tradition alive with a beautiful engagement ring

NTA, use the necklace as an engagement ring. Mom’s being contradictory

NTAs can reset heirloom stones to modernize style, but consider family feelings.

NTA, but consider alternative rings. Tradition isn’t everything.

User feels bad for OP who destroys family heirloom. ESH

Engagement doesn’t have to be expensive Personal sentiment shared.

Buying your own ring? NTA, but consider waiting for sentimentality
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/907501ac-59a1-4659-a288-21df84ea2801.png)
A thoughtful solution to honor grandma’s memory with a ring

Diamond drama: Commenter supports using grandma’s gift for engagement ring.

Daughter stands up to entitled mother over family heirloom
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/4814e899-6323-4f7d-94bc-c0035fca6349.png)
Recycle grandma’s necklace for engagement ring? NTA says comment.

NTA for wanting to use grandma’s necklace/stones for engagement ring

Consider your mom’s feelings and opt for an inexpensive ring

Diamonds are forever, but family drama is eternal ♀️

Creative solution proposed for heirloom diamond dilemma. #NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/cdeee4df-55c2-4490-b60a-64cc33eea0da.png)
Using late grandma’s diamond for engagement ring: ESH, YTA for not considering mom’s feelings
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/d1c161e1-0e84-4481-8cf5-d3a6988121ed.png)
Consider other stones for a beautiful and affordable ring
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/edf3bb44-5de9-472a-b612-5ec0dfcd4b0c.png)
Grandma’s diamond sparks debate on sentimental value vs practicality.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/d5cc429d-86b3-4a98-a84a-9ad02659765f.png)